Ice Hockey Review

10/10/05

Home
SGN Reviews
GT4 Screenshots
Reviews/Articles
Links
History of Soccer Gaming
Contact Us

 

Ice Hockey (NES)

        - The Great One

System: NES
Year: 1988
Developer: Nintendo
The Skinny: 
•	Classic console ice hockey and still one of the best multiplayer experiences around
The Good: 
•	Addictive, skillful and balanced gameplay
•	Fantastic multiplayer
The Bad: 
•	Few teams
•	No tournament or season mode
 

        

Overview

The ‘Tecmo Bowl’ of hockey games, Nintendo’s Ice Hockey is a simple yet wonderfully addictive hockey title that still provides a hell of a lot of fun 17 years after its release.

Graphics

The screenshots pretty much speak for themselves with regards to the rink graphics and player models. The game takes a birds-eye view of the proceedings, but unlike common hockey games of the past decade or so, the game flows from right to left, rather than up and down. I always thought it was kind of odd that as soccer games progressed, the default gameplay views became more like those you see on TV, however in hockey games the default views have always been an up/down ¾ view since EA Sports’ Hockey series started. You might have also noticed that the games are 4 skaters vs. 4 skaters (rather than 5 vs. 5), but I’ll talk about that a bit later.

There are three different player models, skinny guys, medium sized guys, and voluptuous guys. Okay, they’re fat, but I just wanted to use the word ‘voluptuous’ in a review. The animations for each, however, are the same and fairly basic with separate animations for skating, shooting, checking, getting knocked down and celebrating a goal. Jerseys are simple two colour jobs and the ref even makes an appearance to drop the puck every once in a while. In between the 2nd and 3rd periods you’re also treated to the zamboni’s coming out to clear the ice (and, oddly, you can’t skip the sequence).

Sound

Crowd sounds. Rink sounds. Crap 8-bit music. An auditory minimalist masterpiece….not really, but again it’s an 8-bit sports game so the bar isn’t exactly set high.

Options

The options department is probably the only area where Ice Hockey is a let-down, even for its time. The game features a paltry 6 (yes, six!) international teams; Canada, USSR, USA, Sweden, Poland and Czechoslovakia. However, the short list of teams isn’t the main reason why Ice Hockey is a bit of a disappointment; the real shocker is that there is no tournament or season mode! That’s right, all you can do is play exhibition games! Now, while it’s important to note that Ice Hockey’s greatest strength is its multiplayer, it would have been nice to have at least a basic tournament mode. Other options do include the ability to choose the length of the periods (either 7, 10, 15 minutes), the game speed (from 1 to 5), and the composition of your team (do you want two skinny guys and two fat/voluptuous guys, or do you want all medium? Would you like fries with that?).

Gameplay

No Advanced vs. Simple control schemes here, no tie-up button, no deke button, and (thankfully) no fucking sliders – like most 8-bit games Ice Hockey’s control is all about simplicity and it pulls it off perfectly. When you don’t have the puck A is to switch players and B is to check. When you do have possession of the puck B is to pass and A is to shoot (the longer you hold it down the harder the shot, though you cannot skate while charging up your shot). The d-pad governs the movement of the skater you’re controlling, and it also simultaneously moves your goalie in his crease. This rather simple control method allows for one of the aspects of Ice Hockey’s gameplay that really sets it apart from other games; the manual goalie control.

One of the things that still bugs me about today’s ice hockey games is the sense of randomness when it comes to the goalie skill. It’s so common in today’s hockey games to pepper 50-60 shots on goal with no result and have 10 two-on-ones thwarted, only to have the goalie let in a simple floater from the blue line. This is frustrating enough against the CPU, but in multiplayer, when bragging rights are on the line it can be absolutely infuriating to have the CPU largely ‘decide’ when you’re going to score (of course this is due to the fact that developers have to compensate for poor defense and an unrealistic flow of the game by having super goalies, but that’s a rant for another night). Ice Hockey does away with this problem by having the player himself control the keeper and as such there can be no complaints about the CPU screwing you over by letting in a ‘soft one’. The system by which you control your goaltender is also incredibly intuitive because you’re always controlling your net minder (he doesn’t go wandering about because his movement’s confined to his goal crease) and the smaller rink size (along with the zoomed out camera angle) allows you to easily follow shots coming from beyond the red line.

There’s also a nice bit of strategy present when it comes to picking your team. The fat guys move slowly but have howitzers and can check the shit out of other players. The skinny guys have slow shots and can be checked easily, but they’re also the fastest players on the ice and the best at taking face-offs. As you can guess, the medium sized guys are somewhere in the middle. Selecting the make-up of your 4 skater team is a lot of fun and allows you to tailor your lineup to your style of play. You can also choose whom you want to take face-offs by pressing the B button before the ref drops the puck which allows you to have just one token skinny face-off guy on your team if you desire.

The flow of the game is fast and full of action. That you’re controlling the goalies adds so much to the excitement and even though there isn’t a massive variation in the actual types of goals you score (you’ll never draw a goalie out and deke him, neither will you do a wraparound) the build-up play leading to goals is almost always unique. As I’ve mentioned before, the real star in Ice Hockey is the multiplayer which, due to the balanced nature of the game, is always a riot.

Longevity/Replay Value

In single player there isn’t much here, especially by today’s standards. There’s no tournament mode whatsoever and a miniscule selection of teams. But it’s still a great game though to just pick up and play the odd game here and there. Of course, the multiplayer is phenomenal – it’s too bad there was no four player adapter for the old NES….

Overall

I think the biggest praise that I can give Ice Hockey is that, between Winning Eleven, NHL2K5, NFL2K5 and Top Spin, it still gets a multiplayer shout when my friends and I get together for a multiplayer gaming session. Amidst 128-bit games all released in the past year or two is a 17 year old 8-bit gem that shows, once again, that gameplay is the king of all.

Lavan Chandran

5/7/2005

Screenshots taken by me.

 

 

Home | SGN Reviews | GT4 Screenshots | Reviews/Articles | Links | History of Soccer Gaming | Contact Us

This site was last updated 08/06/05